About Us
At New Carlisle First United Methodist Church, our mission is to embody the love of God by knowing Him deeply, growing in Jesus, and showing love through action. Our vision is to be a community where hearts are transformed, hope is restored, and lives flourish. Together, we strive to create a place of spiritual growth, inclusion, and impactful outreach, nurturing every step of your faith journey.
Beliefs And Values
Our church is rooted in core beliefs that celebrate the transformative power of God’s love:
• Faith in Action: We actively demonstrate God’s grace through service and compassion.
• Inclusivity: Everyone is welcome, no matter where they are on their spiritual journey.
• Community: We grow together, forming relationships that reflect God’s love.
• Hope and Renewal: We trust in God’s power to heal and renew lives.
• Accessibility: Worship spaces are designed for everyone, ensuring all feel welcome and included.
History of the Church
Founded in the heart of New Carlisle, our church has been a beacon of faith and service for generations. For decades, New Carlisle First United Methodist Church has impacted lives through worship, community service, and mission projects. We honor our legacy while embracing innovative ways to serve God’s purpose in the modern world, creating a spiritual home for all who seek God’s love.
Our Ministries
Bethel Churches United Food Pantry
Bethel Churches United is a group of local churches in the New Carlisle and Bethel Township community. Its purpose is to lead all people into a closer relationship with the Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, and to glorify God in all that we do. Together, the churches of BCU minister to those in need and provide spiritual leadership to the Bethel Township community.
The Food Pantry is located at the FUMC Family Center at 226 South Pike St. The hours of operation are Wednesday 4:00-5:30pm and Friday from 12:00 noon to 2:00 pm.
Angel House Children’s Home
This ministry began at New Carlisle FUMC in 2003 and has grown into an
international mission project serving a Children’s Home in Tarime, Tanzania, as well as a school.
Vision
Angel House Children’s Home exists for the orphaned and abandoned
children of East Africa and strives to educate a faithful, self-sufficient generation that will positively impact the lives of others.
Mission
Angel House Children’s Home will care for orphaned and abandoned
children by providing spiritual formation academic education, life skills development, and an emotional and physically stable environment in
partnership with the local communities in East Africa
Chancel Choir
A multi-talented group of volunteers provides beautiful music to enrich our services in order that we may praise God. The Choir performs September through May every Sunday during worship as well as on special occasions. New voices are always welcome.
Sunday Growth
Join us on Sunday mornings for our Sunday Growth Groups. Give us a call
for the specific groups and the time and place they meet.
Prayer & Share
The group meets on Sunday evening at 6:30 in the library to share prayer
concerns and pray for those concerns including our church, the local community and the greater world community. During prayer time some individuals will pray aloud. From time to time the group will do a study. All are welcome to attend.
Mission Meals Ministry
Our Mission Meals Ministry prepares and freezes meals to support members of our church community in times of need and to assist foster families through Isaiah’s Place Foster Care Agency.
AA
AA meets in the Church Lounge every Monday at 12:00 noon. If you or someone you know needs this group support, you are welcome anytime. Contact the church office for more information.
NA
NA gathers at the church every Sunday at 6:00 p.m. If you or someone you know could benefit from this supportive group, you’re welcome to join us at anytime. For more details, reach out to the church office.
Guiding Shepherd Christian School
All children in grades Kindergarten through 12th are welcome here. We are licensed by the Ohio Department of Education. Bus transportation is available for full-time students. For more information contact Bambi Heck at (937) 845-3015 or the school office at (937) 845-3292.
Nursery Care
Nursery care is available upon request during our worship service and Sunday Growth Groups.
Bible Studies
We offer a variety of Bible Studies throughout the year to help individuals grow in faith and community. Call the church office to learn about our current study opportunities and how you can get involved.
Our Staff
Meet Bob Lybarger
Senior Pastor
Bob plays a vital role at New Carlisle First United Methodist Church, offering his leadership and unwavering dedication
to the church community. His passion for faith and service shines through in his work, helping to foster a welcoming and supportive environment for all. Whether he’s assisting with church initiatives or offering encouragement, Bob’s commitment to knowing God, growing in Jesus, and showing love in action is evident in all that he does.
Meet Judy Kindred
Administrative Assistant
Judy is a cherished member of the New Carlisle First
United Methodist Church team, bringing warmth,
kindness, and a deep commitment to ministry. She is
dedicated to nurturing spiritual growth and building
meaningful connections within the church community.
Whether she’s lending a helping hand or offering a
friendly smile, Judy embodies the heart of New Carlisle
FUMC’s mission—creating a place where faith flourishes
and love is put into action.
Accessibility
At New Carlisle First United Methodist Church, we are committed to creating a welcoming and inclusive environment for everyone. Our facilities feature:
Elevator Access: Ensuring mobility for all members and visitors.
Accessible Seating: Designed for comfort and inclusion in all worship and gathering spaces.
Family-Friendly Spaces: Including a nursery and areas for children to engage and grow.
Accommodations for All: From welcoming entrances to supportive resources, we strive to make worship accessible to all.
